Years ago you had to mix cookie dough by hand and in fact all dough, cake mixtures and batters had to be hand-made. Some people prefer to mix and knead by hand but of course, now you have the option of using an electric mixer, be it a hand mixer or a stand mixer.

If you are going to make cookies, you will need to use the beater attachment as cookie dough is pretty lightweight. It doesn’t need the power of dough hooks, but at the same time, it’s too heavy for whisks.

In this article, we are going to look at the advantages and disadvantages of mixing cookie dough with a hand mixer and I will give you my 5 top choices of the best hand mixers for cookie dough.

Braun HM5100 MultiMix Hand Mixer, Black
Dash SHM01DSBU Smart Store Compact Hand Mixer Electric for for Whipping + Mixing Cookies, Brownies, Cakes, Dough, Batters, Meringues & More, 3 speed, Aqua
Hamilton Beach 6-Speed Electric Hand Mixer with Snap-On Storage Case, Wire Beaters, Whisk and Bowl Rest, 250W, White (62682RZ)
VonShef BLACK 250W Hand Mixer Whisk With Chrome Beater, Dough Hook, 5 Speed and Turbo Button + Balloon Whisk
KitchenAid KHM7210CU 7-Speed Digital Hand Mixer with Turbo Beater II Accessories and Pro Whisk - Contour Silver
Braun HM5100 MultiMix Hand Mixer, Black
Dash SHM01DSBU Smart Store Compact Hand Mixer Electric for for Whipping + Mixing Cookies, Brownies, Cakes, Dough, Batters, Meringues & More, 3 speed, Aqua
Hamilton Beach 6-Speed Electric Hand Mixer with Snap-On Storage Case, Wire Beaters, Whisk and Bowl Rest, 250W, White (62682RZ)
VonShef BLACK 250W Hand Mixer Whisk With Chrome Beater, Dough Hook, 5 Speed and Turbo Button + Balloon Whisk
KitchenAid KHM7210CU 7-Speed Digital Hand Mixer with Turbo Beater II Accessories and Pro Whisk - Contour Silver
Braun HM5100 MultiMix Hand Mixer, Black
Braun HM5100 MultiMix Hand Mixer, Black
Dash SHM01DSBU Smart Store Compact Hand Mixer Electric for for Whipping + Mixing Cookies, Brownies, Cakes, Dough, Batters, Meringues & More, 3 speed, Aqua
Dash SHM01DSBU Smart Store Compact Hand Mixer Electric for for Whipping + Mixing Cookies, Brownies, Cakes, Dough, Batters, Meringues & More, 3 speed, Aqua
Hamilton Beach 6-Speed Electric Hand Mixer with Snap-On Storage Case, Wire Beaters, Whisk and Bowl Rest, 250W, White (62682RZ)
Hamilton Beach 6-Speed Electric Hand Mixer with Snap-On Storage Case, Wire Beaters, Whisk and Bowl Rest, 250W, White (62682RZ)
VonShef BLACK 250W Hand Mixer Whisk With Chrome Beater, Dough Hook, 5 Speed and Turbo Button + Balloon Whisk
VonShef BLACK 250W Hand Mixer Whisk With Chrome Beater, Dough Hook, 5 Speed and Turbo Button + Balloon Whisk
KitchenAid KHM7210CU 7-Speed Digital Hand Mixer with Turbo Beater II Accessories and Pro Whisk - Contour Silver
KitchenAid KHM7210CU 7-Speed Digital Hand Mixer with Turbo Beater II Accessories and Pro Whisk - Contour Silver

Top 5 Best Hand Mixers for Kneading Cookie Dough

Braun HM5100 MultiMix Hand Mixer, Black

Braun HM5100 MultiMix Hand Mixer, Black

Check Price on Amazon

I have chosen this Braun hand mixer as my top choice of hand mixers which can mix cookie dough. Not only does it have a choice of 9 speeds and a turbo setting as well, but as it has 350 watts it is 50% more powerful than competitors.

This hand mixer is very comfortable to use as it has a super-soft grip. In addition, it is very light and easy to use as it is made with smartmix technology. This moves the weight of the mixer from your hand to the bowl. This has been evolved by creating an in-line vertical motor design.

It’s easy to change the speed while you are mixing. The mixer has a Vario control speed dial and all you need to do is touch a button and then the speed will change.

The same goes for changing the attachments. That’s also done with the touch of a button. It has 4 accessories; 2 multi whisks which are both a whisk and beater in one and are ideal for cookie dough, and 2 dough hooks which are perfect for mixing homemade bread. The mixer comes with an accessory storage bag.

Sale
Braun HM5100 MultiMix Hand Mixer, Black
  • 50% more power* 350 watts of power beats the ingredients and the competition. *Wattage and mixing effort (mixing cake batter, external tests) compared to leading competitors.
  • Half the mixing effort* smartmix technology delivers an in-line vertical motor design that shifts the Weight of the mixer out of your hand and into the bowl. Mixing effort (mixing cake batter, external tests) compared to leading competitors.
  • Quick cleanup easyclean design has a completely sealed system, so nothing gets inside the housing, and dishwasher-safe parts make cleaning easy
  • One-Handed variocontrol a simple turn of the variocontrol speed dial is all it takes to adjust the speed while you mix, and the touch of a button lets you switch between accessories.
  • Attachments for every task multiwhisk, both whisk and beater in one, creates volume for light, airy mixtures. The sturdy dough hooks are perfect for homemade bread and pizza.

The mixer is completely sealed so you won’t get any splashes inside the housing. Just the touch of a button removes the attachments. They are dishwasher safe which makes life easier.

This is my top choice because it has 9 speeds and is ideal for mixing cookie dough. It is comfortable to use and easy to operate.

Dash SHM01DSBU Smart Store Compact Hand Mixer Electric

Dash SHM01DSBU Smart Store Compact Hand Mixer Electric

Check Price on Amazon

This hand mixer, which comes with 2 beaters, is a cheerful aqua color and you can buy items to match, such as a toaster. It has 3 speed settings; low, medium and high. It will easily mix up cookie dough as well as whipping egg whites and cream. All this can be done with just the touch of a button.

This hand mixer only weighs around 2 pounds and is easy to store and to carry with you if you are traveling in an RV. It’s great if you have just a small kitchen as it can be stored in a drawer. In addition, it has a clip plate to store your beaters. Just eject the beaters, clean them and then pop them into the clip. An added bonus is that the beaters are dishwasher safe.

Dash SHM01DSBU Smart Store Compact Hand Mixer Electric for for Whipping + Mixing Cookies, Brownies, Cakes, Dough, Batters, Meringues & More, 3 speed, Aqua
  • 3 speeds: low, medium, or high speed controls let you quickly mix, blend, or whip egg whites, cake batter, cookie dough, whip cream and more At the touch of a button
  • Beater storage: no more lost beaters or flimsy front clip plates - seamlessly eject the beaters and pop them, freshly cleaned, right back into the beater storage clip on the side of the appliance, making for optimum storage
  • Compact + portable: weighing just over 2 lbs, This is a must-have for that first apartment, smaller kitchen, college dorm life, or camper/RV traveling
  • Perfect gift: the perfect wedding or new home gift. Its small size takes up little cabinet or counter space, and its sleek design and trendy color options will match any kitchen décor (add to your registry now! )
  • Includes: backed by a 1-year manufacturer , The 150-watt 3 Speed Hand mixer includes 2 beaters, recipe book and recipe database access (all non-electric parts are dishwasher safe or easily wiped clean)

The mixer is 150 watts which is powerful enough for making cookie dough. As well as the 2 beaters, a recipe book is included in the package as well as recipe database access.

I like this hand mixer because it is so lightweight, but at the same time is powerful enough to mix the cookie dough.

Hamilton Beach 6-Speed Electric Hand Mixer with Snap-On Storage Case, Wire Beaters, Whisk and Bowl Rest

Hamilton Beach 6-Speed Electric Hand Mixer with Snap-On Storage Case, Wire Beaters, Whisk and Bowl Rest

Check Price on Amazon

This mixer has 6 speeds which gives you a good range for whatever you are mixing. It also has a Quick Burst button which gives you an additional burst of power on whatever speed setting you are using. It has 250 watts of power which isn’t bad for a hand mixer.

It comes with 2 beaters which are great for making cookie dough, and a whisk to make light and airy cakes. It also has a bowl rest which stops drips from falling on your kitchen surface. This is accomplished by a built-in grove in the mixer.

This mixer has a snap-on storage case to put your accessories in. You won’t have problems with losing your attachments as they will be easily on hand.

Sale
Hamilton Beach 6-Speed Electric Hand Mixer with Snap-On Storage Case, Wire Beaters, Whisk and Bowl Rest, 250W, White (62682RZ)
  • MIX WITH EASE: With 6 speeds, including the QuickBurst button, you can adjust this kitchen mixer to accommodate any recipe
  • EASY TO HANDLE: With 250 watts of peak power hand mixer
  • BOWL REST FEATURE: A built in groove lets you rest the hand mixer over the bowl, so drips go where they belong and not all over your countertop
  • VERSATILE ATTACHMENTS: The kitchen mixer includes easy to clean set of traditional beaters and whisk
  • SNAP ON STORAGE CASE: This hand mixer includes a handy snap on storage case no more lost beaters

It is very compact. Its measurements are just 9.2” x 8.3” x 5.7” so it can be easily stored in a kitchen drawer.

I like this hand mixer because it is so small, yet it can still make cookie dough. In addition, it has 6 speeds with an extra boost of power if needed

Vonshef Black 250W Hand Mixer

Vonshef Black 250W Hand Mixer

Check Price on Amazon

This hand mixer has 5 speeds and a turbo button which gives an extra boost of power whenever you need it. It has 250 watts.

It comes with 2 beaters, a balloon whisk and 2 dough hooks. You will need to use the chrome beaters to make your cookie dough. The beaters are also ideal for creaming ingredients and making lightweight cakes and batters. You can use the balloon whisk for mixing egg whites to a soft peak. The dough hooks are perfect for making a heavier dough, like bread.

The mixer is easy to use as it is thumb-operated. Beat or whisk with one hand while changing the speed setting with the other. The lowest speed suits mashing vegetables and mixing gravy, while a medium speed is good for cookie dough. Speed 5 should be used for whipping egg whites and whipping cream.

VonShef BLACK 250W Hand Mixer Whisk With Chrome Beater, Dough Hook, 5 Speed and Turbo Button + Balloon Whisk
  • POWERFUL - 250W motor to whisk, mix and knead
  • ACCESSORIES - 2x Beaters, 2x Dough Hooks and a Balloon Whisk
  • 5 SPEED SETTINGS - Also includes turbo function and ejection button
  • LIGHTWEIGHT - Convenient and easy to use due to lightweight nature
  • STYLISH - Stylish and sleek hand mixer in a robust silver and black design

I like this mixer because you can knead, mix and whisk with it. It is ideal for cookie dough. It only weighs 2.65 pounds so is easy to take with you if you are travelling in an RV. It’s also very smart looking with a silver and black design.

KitchenAid KHM7210CU 7-Speed Digital Hand Mixer

KitchenAid KHM7210CU 7-Speed Digital Hand Mixer

Check Price on Amazon

This hand mixer is just 150 watts, but it still has the power to mix cookie dough. It has 7 speeds which will enable you to bake and cook a wide variety of dishes.

If you want to stir in heavier ingredients use the first speed. Speed 4 is good for mashing potatoes. Speed 5 will make your cookie dough, while speed 7 beats egg whites. It has a soft start feature so it gradually reaches each speed setting. This will help to stop splattering all over your worktop.

The accessories this hand mixer comes with are a whisk and 2 beaters. The beaters will mix your cookie dough in no time. It’s easy to remove the accessories from the machine. All you have to do is press a button. The accessories are made from hard-wearing stainless steel.

KitchenAid KHM7210CU 7-Speed Digital Hand Mixer with Turbo Beater II Accessories and Pro Whisk - Contour Silver
  • 7 Speeds: Combine ingredients at speed one for slowly stirring in chunky ingredients, speed four for mashing potatoes, speed seven for beating egg whites and whipping meringue.
  • Soft Start Feature brings the beaters up to the selected speed gradually to help prevent ingredients from splattering.
  • Lock the cord into either the left or right side of the mixer so you can approach ingredients from any angle. The round cord is easy to wipe clean.
  • Soft Grip Handle provides comfort while mixing.
  • Easily and quickly remove any accessory from the hand mixer with the single-handed press of a button.60 Hertz

You can lock the cord into either the right or left side of the mixer. This lets youmix the ingredients from any angle. The cord is easy to wipe clean and the accessories can go in the dishwasher.

I like this mixer because it has a good range of speeds and is capable of mixing cookie dough. An added bonus is that it has a soft-grip handle so you can mix in comfort.

Hand Mixer or Stand Mixer?

So do you buy a hand mixer or a stand mixer to mix your cookie dough? If you just bake cookies now and again you might just want to start with a hand mixer.

They can easily handle cookie dough.  If you bake a lot, you might want to consider a stand mixer. They can handle heavier and denser dough, but a hand mixer is more than capable of making cookie dough.

An important thing to consider is the price. Hand mixers are much cheaper than stand mixers so if you are on a budget you might as well get a hand mixer for your cookie dough.

Hand Mixer Advantages

Hand mixers don’t take up a lot of room in the kitchen, while stand mixers need a substantial work surface and a big cupboard to store them in. Some hand mixers even come with storage cases which will take the cable as well as the attachments.

Another advantage of hand mixers is that they are light and very easy to operate. Even children can use them. Some stand mixers are more complicated to use as they have different programs. All you have to do with a hand mixer is get it out of the cabinet, plug it in, switch it on and turn it to the correct speed.

Hand mixers are easy to clean as they come with detachable beaters and other attachments. Most have dishwasher safe attachments, while a lot of stand mixers don’t.

Hand Mixer Advantages

Hand mixers don’t take up a lot of room in the kitchen, while stand mixers need a substantial work surface and a big cupboard to store them in. Some hand mixers even come with storage cases which will take the cable as well as the attachments.

Another advantage of hand mixers is that they are light and very easy to operate. Even children can use them. Some stand mixers are more complicated to use as they have different programs. All you have to do with a hand mixer is get it out of the cabinet, plug it in, switch it on and turn it to the correct speed.

Hand mixers are easy to clean as they come with detachable beaters and other attachments. Most have dishwasher safe attachments, while a lot of stand mixers don’t.

When is it Best to Mix by Hand?

Although a mixer makes life a lot easier, there are times when old-fashioned mixing comes into play and does a much better job. For example, if you want lightly beaten eggs you just need a fork or a wire whisk. Folding also needs to be done by hand. This is because it is a gentle action which doesn’t need the power of an electric mixer.

It is best to fold if you are stirring egg whites into cake batter or chocolate chips into cookie dough. In addition, don’t use an electric mixer if you are mixing something over heat, such as melting chocolate.

Yes, mixing by hand is necessary in some cases, but if you want to make cookie dough, cream butter or beat egg whites, use an electric mixer.

Final Thoughts

I hope that you’ve found a suitable hand mixer for cookie dough from my choices. Hand mixers are fine for cookie dough. It’s only when you move onto heavier doughs that you might need a stand mixer.

I have chosen the Braun as my no 1 mixer for cookie dough as it is the most powerful machine of all the others I’ve mentioned. It also has Vario control meaning that you only need to turn the speed dial to the correct speed while you are mixing. It has 9 speeds and a turbocharge.

Cookie dough needs to be mixed with a beater and most hand mixers have these. You don’t have to worry about getting a mixer with dough hooks as they are only needed when making things like pizzas and bread.

Hand mixers have plenty of advantages. They are easy to clean and are usually lightweight so they can be used by kids as well as adults. They don’t take up that much space so are great if you have a small kitchen. They can easily slip into a drawer and some even have storage cases so you can keep all the accessories together and not worry about replacing them.

I think it’s a good idea to start off with a hand mixer if you are new to baking and then perhaps invest in a stand mixer. Hand mixers are much cheaper than stand mixers so if you don’t intend to do any serious baking you probably won’t need one.

With all these great hand mixers about you really don’t need to mix by hand anymore; that is unless you want to.